Follow
Share

My boyfriend and I have been together for more than three years. We do love each other and would like to get married one day and share our future together. He is divorced and has adult children who do not live with him. I am a single mom to a 12 year old girl, I have never been married and her father has never been in her life. We both have been living with my elderly parents in their home since she was born, at the time my parents were healthier and able to live independently for the most part. I also work full time and have some of my own health issues. My father now almost 90 and my mom a bit younger but has many serious health problems as well as mobility problems. She can not climb stairs and cannot walk without her walker. They have their beds set up in the living room. My father still does drive but very little. I help them as much as I can as well as help maintain the home inside and out. They have personal care workers that come a few times a week to help with showers and some light duties. My father has someone for snow removal and cutting grass. But I know that personal help they get from outside the home would not be nearly enough to sustain them living on their own. Since I’ve had my daughter up until almost four years ago, I focused strictly on my daughter, my job, my parents and the home. Although I was exhausted all of the time, I have no regret. But it does get lonely. So I met this man a little over three years ago, and I do want a future with him. But I don’t know how to pick up and have my own life? I know my parents need me, they wouldn’t be able to live in their home on their own. And then there is my daughter to consider, she grew up with my parents from birth, they are her home. And they are extremely attached to her as well. So it’s not only the physical care but the emotional devastation that would cause to my daughter and my parents, especially my father. I really feel stuck. I want my own life but not at the expense of my family. Of course my boyfriend knew the situation from the beginning, and he accepted it. We talked about him moving in to my parents house as well, until the time is right and we can have our own home. Ideally I would live very close to them so that I could check in with them daily. I know that this isn’t an easy thing for him to deal with either, he has no ties so he just wants me to leave and get an apartment with him, he doesn’t address how we will care for my parents, he just says I have two other siblings and they can worry about it. One of my siblings lives in another province and the other is married with two small children with their own home. I just feel it’s very selfish of him to just expect me to abandon them without a care or a plan. In fact he talks about living in areas that are quite far from my parents, not to mention my daughters life would be completely uprooted, taken out of the home she’s always known, different school, new friends and at a very delicate age as well. I’m so torn, I feel guilty if I move, I feel guilty if I don’t move, but mostly I feel angry at the way he wants to go about it. Without a care about how this will impact my family members that do need me. I really don’t know what to do. I’m chronically depressed.
He’s pushing me to move out with him, he says I need to grow up! He’s acting as if I’m 25 living at home while my parents cater to me. I’m a middle aged woman working full time, raising my daughter on my own, while taking care of my elderly parents...house and home. I’m stuck between a rock and a hard place I guess. I really don’t know what to do. I feel stuck. And I just wanted to mention as well that he has brought up wanting to get married about a year into the relationship, yet he has not proposed. I mentioned this to him and he said he will never propose until we live together first. Am I supposed to create chaos in my family just so he can test drive me? But no real commitment?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Love. Duty. Commitment. It's all here, life & all it's messy complications.

You are caught in the middle with no clear path & I feel you need more than my little 2 cents here. Have you tried professional counselling at all? Someone impartial to listen & work out the priorities with. These are big issues.

Not being crushed under the weight of responsibility & pressure is first. Looking after yourself! The fact you are reaching out for advice is a good step but you may need more than a forum.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

If you are going to make a mistake, make a big mistake and get married. At both your ages, you don' really need bother with a "TEST DRIVE". he is dangling a carrot in front of you to make you move out.. yet, he cannot propose to you now, and get married... why? because he's not sure? If he wants to test drive, then he should move into your home with your parents. Maybe he should grow up, and be open minded to your life and what it means to be taking care of some the most important people in your life.

Nothing in life is guaranteed, but your love and devotion to your parents and daughter = family, biological, is strong.. That for sure is a guarantee. If you did uproot to move in with him, and something happened, and you did not have a plan in place, you would feel guilty...
maybe both of you should see a marriage counselor now, together. He is divorced and you never married... So, maybe perhaps, do see a counselor.

Beatty is right. THESE ARE BIG ISSUES.

do not make any sudden decisions. think about what you posted, and what beatty posted.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

"...he said he will never propose until we live together first. Am I supposed to create chaos in my family just so he can test drive me? But no real commitment?"

Yes, your BOY friend is selfish. He knows your situation going in, yet he's looking to just pluck you out of the current living situation and plop you down someplace that is ideal and convenient for him only regardless of the damage it will cause you, your parents and your daughter. And he doesn't even want to make a commitment. That's not a man, that's a selfish overgrown boy.

You said you love him. What exactly do you love about his characters? Does he possess kindness and good morals?

Putting your parents' care aside for a moment, just considering the interest of your daughter only, having a step dad like your boyfriend at the pre-teen age going into the rebellious teenage years is going to be very difficult for everyone, you, him, and specially your daughter. The way you describes him, I would guess once you two get married, he'll demand all of your attention and will look at your daughter as an inconvenience and a burden. There will be a lot of problems.

As for your parents' care, it is going to get harder and harder for you to shoulder all of their care. What is your/their plan when you can't take care of them anymore? With or without your boyfriend, you still need to consider this, because otherwise, you will never have a life of your own. Whatever your plan is, you should take steps towards making it happen NOW. Otherwise, your life will be consumed by your parents' care.

After you have done that, and you can have time to do things for yourself, then you can start looking for a real man, a better man to build your life with.

As for the current boyfriend, I think it's best you dump him as you're just wasting time. Best you use that time to get your parents' affair in order.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

He is in a hurry to enjoy post-parenting, approaching retirement, affluent years; and you are not ready. Your daughter is 12. Your parents, to whom you have every reason to be grateful, rely on you (at the moment, this can gradually change) as an integral part of their way of life.

He's not selfish to want what he wants, and he's not selfish to say what it is, but he is completely selfish and wrong to put pressure on you to the extent of trying to make YOU feel that YOU'RE in the wrong. You are fulfilling several commitments - he may be one, but he's the newest - and you're not finished yet.

It's also an absolutely terrible time (age 12) to think about a radical change in your daughter's family circle. Seriously, don't do it.

You could make gradual changes over the next five to ten years. If that's too slow for him, he needs someone a little older who isn't still so needed by her family, that's all :)
Helpful Answer (15)
Report

You know, it's strange. The prevalent thinking on this site is, as a caregiver, you should put your own family (SO/children) first - or rather, you put yourself, SO and children first. But there seems to be more going on here than just a rift over caregiving.

Since you know this man better than we do, it's time to ask yourself some very difficult questions. Is his attitude really just about you providing care to your parents? Or is it something deeper than that? Is he the sort of person who expects his wife to put everyone/everything else on the back burner to cater to his needs? Has he ever told you the reasons for his divorce? He has said to you he would "never" marry you until you live together first. Is this really someone you want to marry? That sounds an awful lot like an ultimatum; and I don't think that's a good way to enter a marriage. And supposing you do as he asks...leave your parents, uproot your daughter, move in with him, then what? Do you honestly believe he will honor his words and propose? How long does he think he needs a trial run before he's willing to commit? 1 month? 1 year? 5 years?

How old were his children when he divorced their mother? Was he an active part of their lives, or was he just a dad of "convenience" - ie. he would dart into their life when it suited him? Is he willing to allow you to put your daughter's needs ahead of his? I know a lot of married men who come to a point where they resent the time their wives spend with their own kids - do you think he will have patience with yours?

These are questions you would need to answer regardless of your parents needing your care.

I agree with the answers that encourage you to speak with a counselor. There are issues you will need to deal with regardless of your decision about this man...mainly how are you going to handle caretaking as your parents get more and more dependent. You have a right to have a life that is not entirely about taking care of others rather than yourself - the question you have to really ponder is if this man is going to be a part of that life. Is he really looking for a partner with whom to share his life or is he just looking for someone who has caregiving so deeply ingrained into her that she won't mind trading taking care of her parents and child for taking care of her partner.

Good luck in making your decision! I wish you well.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

My personal take has always been family (particularly children) over friend - even boyfriend. I would tell him until your daughter leaves for college or tech school, this is the way it is going to be. Family over boyfriend. It might be a little different if he were a husband of some years, but then he doesn't even want that role since he's asking you change/drop/break everything in your life for a test drive. There are other companions out there. Let this one go and make yourself available for a better man or at least one who values loyalty and respects your commitment to your child. If the boyfriend stays, then he needs to accept your family commitments and stop pressuring you to break them.

Value yourself enough not to give up what's important to you for the possibility of a ring of dubious value. How would you feel if after moving your daughter to some house 50+ miles down the road, your boyfriend decides the test is just not working out for him?
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Your commitment is to your parents until you are married. But he won't marry until you live together first. To live together with no commitment? How would you feel? And what's his idea of marriage? He wants a "test drive" first? And then want?

Muster up your self esteem and bid him farewell.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

"Getting the milk without purchasing the cow..." (that's the one I heard growing up. Crass, but oh so true.

How about: The difference between living together and being married is like the difference between renting and owning. Not that being married means one person "owns" another but it is referring to commitment. Does anyone treat a rental car or rented apartment the same as a car they have bought and paid for? Does anyone invest in improving an apartment they don't own? Nope.

Phoenix, there are 2 issues going on for you: #1 is that you must have a conversation with your parents that you are willing to help manage their care, but not take it on entirely. They are grown-ups and can surely understand this. You will be consumed by their care if you put it all on your shoulders. Just because they want that arrangement doesn't mean they should have it. Read the posts in this forum on Caregiver Burnout.

Then, once you get that clarified in your mind and theirs and have a plan for that, then you can give full attention to your boyfriend. I'm opposed to living together for many reasons, but from a secular standpoint there are ample studies that show it makes NO positive impact on the divorce rate for those who go on the marry. He either loves what he sees in you now, enough to commit, or he should move on. It doesn't matter that he is now gun-shy from a prior divorce. If you have a car accident do you avoid driving? No. Also he doesn't seem to have much compassion for your situation and how much stress he's adding to your life. Not a good sign.

Also, you have a daughter and until you're married, she is priority (after you -- you are #1) and then your parents are third, then the BF. If he doesn't like that arrangement he can move along. Remember that you are modeling the kind of priorities and relationships to your daughter. Don't teach her to be a doormat. I wish you all the best, I wish you wisdom and peace in your heart as you make some very important decisions!
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
notgoodenough May 2020
I like your point between renting and owning...
I have told people who say "why bother with marriage, it's just a piece of paper" - so is the title to your car and the deed to your house. They are also just pieces of paper, but they are pieces of paper that afford you certain legal rights and protections.
(13)
Report
You say he has no care plan in place. He told you that you have 2 other siblings that can handle it, this is the plan he has. Are you willing?

I'm sorry but I find him repulsive, what kind of male says, " let's have a trial run" with a 12 year old girl involved. He wants to show her that women are not valued enough to commit to until you see if they do it well enough to suit you. That just makes me angry.

Your parents were there for you and your daughter when you needed them most. I think that you would not be happy with your life if you let a grown boy make you decide to walk away from them at this point.

Don't get me wrong, I think that you deserve a life and that walking away is always an option, but not because some male wants to play house and dump your responsibilities because they don't suit him.

Under no circumstances should you have him move in to your parents home. He sounds selfish enough to make everyone miserable if he is unhappy.

One thing that I taught the young ladies of my family, if it is true love it will keep until all parties are able to fully commit. If not, it will just dwindle away when it is not getting it's own way. Never sacrifice your heart or beliefs to accommodate someone that professes to love you, love will never ask you to sell yourself that way. He is asking you to forget everything that you believe and care about, I wouldn't call him marriage material.

Your daughter needs stability and committed people in her life, 12 is a very challenging age and she could be damaged by wrong choices made for her. Please don't take everything she knows away from her for a booty call boy.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

Phoenix11,
Something is not right about that guy. He needs to move away. Far, far away. It's time for you to have a long distance relationship with him. Just tell him that it is best that he finds his own place. You are not stuck! He needs to grow up! Stay where you are. Home is where you are supposed to be, Do not worry about the other siblings stepping up. You are the one. Please tell him to go. Then, see how it goes with him. Put him to the test and tell him to drive away, fast!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

All of the advice for you is questioning this guy. When in a relationship it is sometimes very hard to see how it is really going from the inside. From what you say, though, others can see into it, and in this case it seems something is very wrong. You can figure out the care of your parents, which will get harder, but you seem able to be on top of what to do for them. You know what your daughter needs, a stable home, same school, and friends into her teens. He's the problem. I entered a relationship in a similar situation, but I'm older than you. I was working full time, taking care of my mom, and raising a grandson when I met a lovely man. His friends warned him that I had too much "baggage". When he stupidly reported that to me, I nearly sent him away for good. I told him to never refer to my family as baggage again and let him into my messy life. He got to see that I can actually handle it all AND have a relationship. We have been married for 6 years. I would not have lived with him first. I don't like that your boyfriend asks that of you. I'm open minded about that sort of thing, but you seem to actually need the proposal, so stick with that. Do not give up who you are to be in a relationship. Your idea of an apartment with this guy very close to your parents so that you can continue to make sure they have what they need, and your daughter can see them often too, is exactly the answer. Make it clear that marriage is first. He might learn from your wisdom. That or he can go his own way alone.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

As I was reading this... I got upset... at this boyfriend of yours. Something is extremely wrong with him. Believe me.. I know. I had...(the word here is "had") been married to that type. He had already moved away from his family to another state when his parents were in their 60's. He left 3 siblings also. My parents had died years ago. I married him and was married to him for 17 years. Let me tell you...I was the one to go see his parents and took our twins. He stated that he had left his family because of severe allergies. Bull!!! When I divorced him, he followed me to that state that he says he left because of severe allergies and has lived here for 18 years. AND....about his parents? His father died within 2 years after we married. His mother's house was condemned several years later so she had to find another place to live, of course, My ex refused to even discuss that topic. I offered to move back there, get a place and take care of her but no.. he was NOT moving back there! He would have NOTHING to do with helping his mother. He did NOTHING. Would not talk about it and he didn't! I want to tell you this... or ask you, Why is he wanting to marry you? And why are you wanting to marry him? I would get as far away from this man as possible. He has no concern not only about your parents.. your situation but he seriously does not care about you. This is about him and what he wants... and his needs or he would not be acting the way he does. What is HE bringing to this marriage? Where are his parents? He is NOT going to treat you any better than he treats his parents, your parents....I just read someone elses comment. This immature human of the male gender... is repulsive to me also. He should NOT be giving out threats. I will not call him a man.... he is not one. Believe me... you can do better. And your daughter does NOT need to be around someone thinking this is OK. God bless you, honey. You need it.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Phoenix, you’ve gotten really good suggestions from Beatty, PolarBear, CountryMouse, Notgoodenough on the situation with your parents & BF.

I’m going to take another viewpoint, your responsibility NEEDS to be all about your 12 yr old daughter. She is your legal responsibility, not your parents or your BF. She should be first and foremost and that imo means you do whatever you need to be make yourself Capable first and foremost to be able to provide for and care for and participate fully in her life and prepare her for her future.

Imo, your daughter is the one getting short changed in all this.
At age 12, in the US, she’s about to go into 7th grade & middle school, and that has very real drama for her. The shes “very close, extreme devastation” that you think would happen if you & her lived apart from your folks..... well maybe not. Middle schooler living at grands house, unless it’s a rare household, does not work well. Those type of living situations are in my experience because the parents are immigrant families who need to be in intergenerational household to survive; the parents are too poor to afford their own place; the parents are themselves are still emotionally not adult to be their own persons; or kids live with grands cause parents are absent; or Parents on drugs or parents are in jail or prison. Living with grannie, cute when you’re 7 and making cookies; not cute for 14 and doing sleepovers. Whether this is fair or not, is a separate discussion. It’s the reality of tween & teenage in the US, whether boys or girls.

At 12, she’s going to be able to search out and find out about her birth father. Whether you like it or not. Whatever cover or details you have not been up front about on that relationship is coming up. You can’t keep her from contacting him or his family. Gird up its coming.

At 12, she’s going to be searching for her father or a father figure. Your BF, well he comes across as not at all interested in being this. His kids all are grown adults, not on his payroll or responsibility. If he - after what 3+ years of “dating” - is not actually ACTUALLY ACTIVELY part of her life, her school and in school activities, not gonna happen. And by that I do not mean going with you and her to the school fair once a year, but being one of the dads on the list for setting up the school fair. She’s going to find a father figure and for young girls at age 12 is pretty perfect timing for becoming a lil’ street flower. 12-14 is premium young snatch stage & someone is going to recognize her unhappiness and exploit her for their own gain. Doing this is a real option for her and something that parents have blinders on about its existence.

for your daughter’s sake, get counseling and come up with a plan for your own life.
If you think “love” is what your BF behavior is towards you, your own issues are way, way, way beyond what you can deal with on your own, you need to get counseling. You need to find out why you allow yourself to be basically a door mat for others. Do this if not for yourself but for your daughter.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

You can do better than this man, both you and your daughter deserve better. And your parents are blessed to have you looking out for them
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Just curious are your "parents" really grandparents who raised you? Because you say your middle aged with a 12 yr old and sister has 2 small children. Parents must have been in their 40s at least when they had you.

My opinion, your daughter is what is the most important thing here. Parents come second to her. At her age, I wouldn't make any big changes. Your parents are part of her stability. She is going to be an adolescent with all the stuff that goes with that. Seems that you and parents have all ur ducks in a row. Why wreck the status quo for a man who now whats it his way or no way. And please don't move him in. May not work out. Its your parents house anyway.

I see a man who has no responsibilities and doesn't want them. Lets say you move in with him, will he like that you go to Mom and Dads to help? The statement you have other siblings makes me think not. And do you really want to uproot a 12 yr old for something you are questioning?

BF was aware of the situation when he started dating you. He is now realizing this is not what he wants giving you ultimatums. In my experience, ultimatums never work for the good.

I suggest making a list. One side what this man does for you. And then what you do for him. Does he really meet "your" needs. You may be surprised that you have been carrying this relationship. That you have always given over 50%. Wish I had done that before I married my ex. I wouldn't have married him.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I would be very careful about this man. Go with your instincts. You do not want to get in a situation and have regrets later on. Your daughter seems to be in a stable home environment and she is so young and impressionable. You are caring for your parents and he has no right to interfere with your family. I think he has too many needs and is insecure, He appears to be very selfish and controlling. He has no ties, wondering why? I would get out of this relationship ASAP and do not look back. He is giving you an ultimatum about living together before marriage. How wrong is this! I hope you make the right decision and find peace in this decision.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I'm going to focus on your parents..... I think that it is time to make a plan for their future that doesn't necessarily include you. Both of them are inevitably going to decline over the next few years and their care needs will increase - can you see yourself providing intimate personal care for either of them, or god forbid both of them at the same time? I'm talking bathing, toileting, incontinence care, medical issues, struggles with mobility, the possibility of cognitive decline and more. All of us have this dread that one day we shall find a loved one has died in their sleep, but from experience I can tell you that that is the "good" outcome, a blessing that comes to far too few. One of my regrets is that I took the easy route and allowed my mother to live "independently" for far too long in the belief that she should be able to die in her own home - I had no inkling of just how long she could live and how incredibly dependent she would become. I believe it is time for your parents to make plans to downsize to a more supportive environment while they still have the ability to participate in the process, this is both for their sake as well as yours. IMO you and daughter need time to learn to live independently from your parents and they from you before you even consider the next step with BF.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

I suppose that you feel torn in four different directions, your daughter, your parents, yours and your boyfriend.

Your daughter is a serious responsibility. She needs you. I’m sure that she loves you and you love her.

You love your parents and they love you. Your boyfriend fell for a woman with responsibilities. These decisions are your decisions to make, not his.

When you can you may want to talk this over with an objective individual that will help guide you through this.

Best wishes to all of you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I personally, and morally (and don't jump on me for being 'old fashioned') would NEVER have lived with a guy as a 'test drive'. Marriage is a dead serious a comittment as they come. "living together" while one of my daughters did that with her BF for 5 years---I was very happy when they decided to get married. It felt so much more secure and real to me, anyway. (Nobody cares nor cared what I thought).

You have parents and a daughter who all need you. Why can't BF see that? Perhaps he just sees a very caring woman and thinks "yep, that's what I want". I KNOW one of the big reasons my Dh married me is he knew I would be a good caregiver, to our children and to him. It's NOT a bad thing and I have had to step up MANY time to care for him.

I'd say if this guy wanted to move in with the family, you won't have one iota of privacy, but you'll have your dignity.

This is a multi-generational family unit that seems to be working. Why upset the apple cart for some guy who wants YOU to make all the changes while he gets a homemaker and wife to boot. What is HE giving up in this situation? Not much, it seems.

Take your time to decide this. Once you move out for 'the test drive' (that is kind of offensive, when I think about it) you will have upset what seems to be a very well functioning family situation.

Good Luck.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Thank you so much to each and every one of you for taking the time to send out your love and support, your insight and advice as well as some of your own personal stories. This is helping me tremendously, I’m overwhelmed (in a good way)
I’ve been harbouring so much of this for so long, it’s hard to talk to family because of the repercussions that would follow. Although I have confided in a couple of close friends who have been very supportive, it really does help to also get some unbiased insight and feedback. And I truly am grateful for all of this support. I wanted to give a little bit more background as I know some of you have asked some questions. There are huge age gaps in my family. My father will be 89 this year and my mother is 13 years younger than him. I am 52, and am the middle child of three siblings, the oldest is 6 years older than me and the youngest is ten years younger. I had my daughter at the ripe age of 39.
My daughter has reached out to her father about three years ago with my help but he wasn’t interested. It was quite painful but we have leaned to accept it and move forward. I’ve told her everything she needed to know in the most positive way possible. She has always been a happy, energetic and social girl. Going through puberty now though, she is very sensitive and moody. She is my life and my first priority. Being a shy introvert myself, I used to say that she is raising me, everywhere we went together, I would have to speak to people I dint know, and I started overcoming my shyness because of her. I really did hope that this man in my life that I really did love and care for could have added to our family. The truth is, and many of you were so right on this with only a tidbit of information, and that is that he doesn’t have any patience for my daughter, he acts as if my raising is done. In the past we argued a lot because he would say that kids don’t need vacations, they don’t need this or that. We only did less than a hand full of outings with her in three years. And I had to beg him. And they weren’t fun because at some point he lost his temper, either because he couldn’t find parking, driving, too many people etc. Since getting back together after a recent break up, he has promised to be more involved in my daughter’s life, along with so many other promises that have yet to happen. Any little thing that he has done for me or my family has been thrown in my face at every chance.
No one is perfect, I understand that, I’m far from it myself. I don’t want perfect, just someone who actually loves and cares.
He has just recently told me that I expect him to do everything while I do nothing. That he has to make all the compromises to be together. He lives in a rented apartment on his own. His children are independent and in fact have never lived with him since his divorce about 15 years ago. He resents that our decisions must revolve around my daughter and my parents. When I tell him that I don’t feel like he and I are a team, he says we can’t be a team because I live with my parents, we can only be a team when we are on our own. When I question the way he treats me, for example, never takes me out or does anything special for my birthday, valentines etc, he says he can’t be that person while I live with my parents and that I am delusional for thinking I am entitled to any of those things. He said he can’t be the man I want him to be because I can’t and won’t be the woman I should be because I won’t move out to be with him. I know I must sound extremely pathetic by now, but the truth is when he first came into my life, he was a completely different person. I fell in love with the person I thought he was, with the idea that it wasn’t too late to have love and companionship, a father figure in my daughters life. But all of you have confirmed what my gut has been telling me, what logic has been telling me. I will not be moving anywhere with him. Thank you all for helping me see that.
Helpful Answer (14)
Report
ellbee May 2020
You deserve so much better than this guy.
(10)
Report
See 5 more replies
I lived with my DH before we married, but we both wanted that.   I don't want to make judgements on either of you, I just don't see this working for you both right now
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Your situation is different because you have a 12 y. o. daughter to raise.
That should be your priority. You have said: " She is my life and my first priority.". Good for you!

Do not believe "your boyfriend", he sounds like a controlling narcissist, has anger issues.

If you 'dance away', he may get desperate.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

I guess u don't need to make that list.😊

They say to date someone for a year because the real person will finally show his face. It may have taken a little longer but I think you realize that he is not who he claimed to be in the beginning. Good for you u saw thru it and just needed confirmation. Time to tell him goodbye. You need someone to love u baggage and all. And he is out there.

I had a neighbor who lost her only daughter. She had a nephew she raised but he wasn't around much. Her SIL did everything for her until she passed. A woman I knew, who had finally divorced an abusive husband and said she would never marry again, married the SIL. I asked her why, she said any man who would have continued to care for a MIL like he did would care for a wife that way too. They have been married for a long time.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

"My boyfriend and I have been together for more than three years."

"My daughter has reached out to her father about three years ago with my help but he wasn’t interested." (Timing is a coincidence?)

"he has brought up wanting to get married about a year into the relationship, yet he has not proposed."

Is it at all possible, Phoenix, that you are causing hurt and confusion in your daughter's life by wanting the best of both worlds?

There is nothing to indicate that your boyfriend wants to include your daughter in his life. I would keep my daughter far away from this boyfriend. I would stop bringing him up, stop bringing up wanting to marry him. Your own confusion and indecision will continue to have a profoundly negative effect on your young daughter. imo.

If you keep your relationship with your boyfriend and do move out, even if you marry him, leave your daughter out of it. imo. She doesn't need to be treated the way he is treating you now.

Your parents seem to have it pretty much under control as far as providing their own care, imo.

I do not see where you have plans to take care of yourself in all of this.

Just some tough reality you could be taking seriously. It is all on you, your decisions. In fact, others will continue to be free to make their own decisions no matter what you do. Imagine a too young girl running away to get married because of her mother's boyfriend or new husband. Or elderly parents being controlled or neglected because boyfriend moves into their home? This option should be totally off the table, imo.

Would counseling help you?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Phoenix11 May 2020
You do make some very good points. It’s never easy making decisions knowing that it will impact so many people we care about, so for now, I’ll do what’s best for my family, my daughter especially. As far as him moving in, that is already off the table. But just for the record, he would never try to control my parents, he has always been respectful and humble in their presence. It’s only to me that he speaks this way. A lot of these issues and behaviours with in our relationship unfolded slowly over time. As far as my daughter, yes this did cause some confusion, as for the first nearly nine years of her life, it was just us, it was an adjustment but she was quite happy and excited about it. (Of course not as of lately) She was thrilled to have someone to make a Father’s Day card for at school, she referred to him as her stepdad to her friends. She was happy to see me happy. Everything seemed perfect for a time. And the timing of wanting to reach out to her biological father was a bit of a coincidence, it actually was a few months before I met my boyfriend, I rounded it off to about three years. A lot of her friends at school started asking her questions and making assumptions about her father. I knew this day would come and it was difficult, but we worked through it the best we could.
The boyfriend looked like a light at the end of the tunnel. I was so wrong.
(5)
Report
When I met my current husband, my daughter was 12 years old at the time. Chuck was the first and only 'boyfriend' she'd ever met; that's how I wanted it. I had dated, but nobody I liked enough to introduce her to. I waited until I met Mr Right, in other words, to get her involved. She had other ideas. She and her BFF Erin decided he had no place in our lives at ALL! So they schemed to get rid of him. Yep, that's what they did, alright! Unbeknownst to me or to my boyfriend at the time.

Chuck loved my daughter, and personally vowed to take us BOTH on, together, as a package deal. The first outing he took DD on was to a CD store. He told her she had unlimited time in the store to browse, and that she could choose any 5 CDs she wanted. It wasn't the CDs that shocked her........it was the offer to spend AS MUCH TIME as she wanted shopping around. Her father never had any time for her at all. His answer to being a father was writing a check. She wasn't used to someone like Chuck.

That was the beginning of THE most beautiful relationship I've ever had the pleasure to witness develop.

She & Erin had no other choice but to ditch their plan to get rid of him!

Chuck has turned into the father her biological father was incapable of being. She's now 28 years old and an RN in a COVID-19 unit in a downtown hospital. She first decided she wanted to be a hairdresser. Chuck was there for her every step of the way; he never told her Oh No Don't Be a Hairdresser. He supported her, whatever she did or did not do. She calls HIM first when she has an issue, then me. Which sometimes irritates me.......LOL. That's the special bond the two of them have. Why? Because he made it his mission to make her his 4th daughter; he has 3 biological daughters, and mine makes 4.

When we met, my parents were living in Florida. We got married in 2009; in 2011, Dad had to stop driving and we moved them here to Colorado (I am an only child). Chuck helped me find them an Independent Living apartment, get them moved in and unpacked, and set up in their new place. He called them Mom & Dad from the get go, and loved them as his own, since he lost his own parents a decade earlier.

Dad passed away in 2015 and my mother is still alive, at 93, living in a Memory Care Assisted Living. She is difficult as the day is long. There are times when I can't deal with her BS, so Chuck calls her on the phone to chat. She loves him and she's always happy to hear from him. Me she treats like crapola............but he's another story. He's always kind and loving and compassionate. He's moved her 4x; from one apartment and ALF to another, with no complaining, no moaning and carrying on, and no payback expected from me.

Chuck earned his way into my family with love, kindness and the utmost of respect for ALL of us. It wasn't always fun or convenient for him, God knows, and I'm sure there are times he'd like to sit down and cry for what my mother puts us through. But he plugs along, for my sake, because he loves me.

Chuck is the type of man YOU need in YOUR life, my dear woman. I waited a long time for God to put him into my life, but He did. And I snapped him up because I recognized what a true gift he was and still is. The day I met him I KNEW. I went into the bathroom at the restaurant where the party was being held, and I sat on the toilet & prayed. I said, "God I know You sent me this man to marry, and I thank You. Now let HIM recognize it too!"

And the rest is history. Say goodbye to your Mr. Wrong and wait for Mr. Right. He's out there somewhere. You just haven't found him yet. You and your daughter and your parents deserve to find him, because you're worth it.
Helpful Answer (16)
Report
elaine1962 May 2020
I lover your answer lealonnie!!! It wouldn’t let me press the like button, lol.
(7)
Report
See 5 more replies
Phoenix, so glad you've come to the conclusion you have; be wary of him, though. Sendhelp aced it when she said he is a "Controlling Narcissist". Please look it up; I have, and it opened my eyes to a great deal of things. God bless, sweetie!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
Phoenix11 May 2020
Thank you, I will for sure...xo
(4)
Report
Dump your boyfriend. He sounds like a jerk. No plan as to how to care for your elderly parents? Move away and uproot your daughter? Live with you but not marry you? I wouldn’t do it. You deserve so much better.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Before you become a permanent dance partner, bitter and resentful of becoming used up, please read this:

https://psychcentral.com/blog/the-dance-between-codependents-narcissists/

And dance away....
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Phoenix11 May 2020
Thank you, I will read it xo
(3)
Report
"...but the truth is when he first came into my life, he was a completely different person. I fell in love with the person I thought he was..."

Pheonix - you are very smart to have second thought about his guy and to have posted your question here to ask for input. Please get rid of him. And don't let him back in no matter what he says.

Here's a few things about abusive and controlling people I found online. See how many of these characteristics match your boyfriend.

"What Is Controlling Behavior? Controlling behavior is when one person expects, compels, or requires others to cater to their own needs — even at others' expense. The controlling person targets an individual and dominates them in an unhealthy, self-serving manner."

"12 Traits of an Abuser:

1. Charming.
Initially, he showers his woman with praise, adoration, and attention. His courtship is sweet and intense filled with phrases such as, “I can’t live without you.” He quickly pushes for an exclusive relationship or engagement.

2. Jealous.
He views other men as a threat to the relationship and accuses you of flirting with everyone from his brother to the mailman. “I know you are looking at him.” The irony is that he often is the one who is cheating.

3. Manipulative.
This man is very intelligent. He knows how to detect your weak spots, and he uses your vulnerability and past pain to his advantage. “You were abused as a kid because you are so ugly.”

4. Controlling.
He wants to know where you are going and who you are with at all times. He may check the mileage on your car or follow you to the grocery store. He often refuses to allow you to work because you might “meet someone.”

5. A Victim.
His poor choices are everyone else’s fault. When he loses his job, gets into a fight, or a business deal falls through, it’s always because of the other person. He is never at fault. “You make me hit you.”

6. Narcissistic.
The whole world revolves around him. As the “little woman who is beneath him,” it is your job to meet his every need. He is the master; you are the unworthy slave. It’s invigorating for him to know that everyone around him “walks on eggshells.”

7. Inconsistent.
Mood swings are a common trait for an abuser. One minute he seems happy and sweet, the next he is pounding his fist.

8. Critical.
No matter how hard you try you will never be able to satisfy this kind of man. He thinks nothing of degrading and verbally assaulting you. “You are a stupid, fat, disgusting tramp. You can never leave me. No other man would have you.”

9. Disconnected.
His main goal is to isolate his victim from family and friends so that you are totally dependant on him. “Your family causes too much trouble for us. I don’t want you seeing them anymore.”

10. Hypersensitive.
The slightest offense sends him ranting. Everyone is out to “get him.”

11. Vicious and cruel.
A significant number of abusers harm children and animals as well as a partner. Inflicting pain and intimidating others is what gives him power. “I’ll kill you before I’ll let you go. If I can’t have you, no one will.”

12. Insincerely repentant.
He will swear to never “hit you again.” But unless he receives professional help and strong accountability it’s very unlikely that he will change.

If this article has helped you to realize that you or a loved one is in an abusive relationship, please find a church, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-SAFE, or locate a safe house in your community. They can help."
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
DonnaF777 May 2020
Yes... I do HOPE and PRAY that she realizes RIGHT NOW.... that this immature human being of a male is abusive. And it is only going to get worse when you marry him. I know.... Mine was nice to me before we got married. Never made demands on me... until AFTER the "I do's" were said. And of course, he never shows his true self to others. Only me and the kids. He does things on purpose to others like showing up late and then makes up something then says he is sorry for being late. AGAIN.. HE WAS LATE ON PURPOSE. He may abuse you.. and probably will if you do marry him and move away from your parents. He will give you trouble and abuse you in some form every time you want to go see them. Please.... do NOT marry this man. Leave him now. There are actually true gentlemen out there. GOD will find one for you in HIS time. Don't settle. I did and my kids are paying for it. They have no dad. He never wanted a relationship with them until he got old (now 74) and he is wanting them to take care of him. He did not even want to go to his son's wedding but he arrived. Then when he got there, he called his son on his wedding day to tell him that he was angry with him for NOT seeing him soon enough after he arrived from out of state! (My ex was invited to come to "the house" to be with everyone.. meet the bride's family but my ex would not come. Instead, he was demanding everyone do as HE wanted. I had to calm him down.... so our son could have his wedding. Do NOT marry someone who treats you like this. And please remember, there are different types of abuse. There is emotional abuse besides the physical abuse. PLEASE...DO NOT MARRY THIS GUY. GET RID OF HIM. NOW... PRONTO...
(8)
Report
See 1 more reply
Another thought...
What your boyfriend is demanding of you:
1) Moving in with him;
2) Putting him before your daughter, mother, and father;
only happens under the commitment of a marriage. Before #1 and #2 happen.

Where the bible talks about leaving and cleaving. The two shall become as one, and leave their parents.

With a 12 year old daughter, and caregiver of your parents, I think your options are less ideal and the test drive is over.

You deserve something closer to the ideal relationship, so wait for it.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
Phoenix11 May 2020
Yes this is exactly what he’s demanding. I mean I’m not against living together, but in my situation I have a lot at stake, that is the main reason I wanted the commitment first. I need to know he is truly invested in me and my whole package before I even consider such a drastic move. And even with commitment, meaning a proposal/engagement, that doesn’t mean I can just pack up and run away with him, I still need to figure things out with my parents, wait until my daughter is at least a little older and or make sure she is ok with it, and in the mean time, we can still be a team, enjoy time together as a couple, as a family, troubleshooting together, being there for one another etc. He is the one who first started talking about marriage, I’ve never pressured him for marriage ever. But now that he’s pressuring me to move out, then I want to know he’s truly committed to me and my daughter. But he won’t. I mean neither of us are getting any younger. what else does he need to know? We’ve travelled together once, we’ve gone camping together with and without kids, I’ve spent time at his place, he’s spent time at mine. He knows all my quirks, habits etc. And he has already seen the ugliest side of me inside and out (LOL)
He knows I’m loyal to a fault...but I’ve reached my limit. And he’s gone too far with the insults, I know we all say things when we’re angry. But it all depends in the context of how we say certain things. Resorting to school ground insults about me still living with my parents throwing in LOL’s here and there and finally calling me a Loser...it got so ridiculous. This was all on text, he doesn’t like to talk on the phone, but I finally called him to tell him to stop harassing me and then I hung up, because the insults on text wouldn’t stop even after I told him to stop or I’ll block him etc. It’s really shocking though, because I’ve never seen this nasty side to him except once, and that is when we had broken up a few months ago. And now history is repeating itself. I think I will take your advice on the ideal relationship...and wait for it...
(9)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter